Friday, November 30, 2007

Overbuilding In Alexandria

Question: Frank,
I just finished my design your dream home class, and the teacher (a retired architect) made some helpful comments on our existing 8000 sq ft design. Anyway, my concern is a realtor
said if we build a house thats big and we would want to sell it for $2 mill, we don't want to build it in our neighborhood since no one in that price range wants to live in our area, is that true generally? The guy said everyone looking at big houses wants N. Arlington, Oakton, Mclean or Great Fall.

  1. Do you agree with the guy's assessment of the market generally?
  2. Do you think we are even crazier for wanting to put a nice big new house on our lot?

Jane

My Reply:

Jane, From a high level perspective, for the most part he sounds right. Ultimately everything is a function of price. I swear you can sell a 8000 SF place there for $500k overnight, right?
So the real question is what amount of losses might you expect for overbuilding in the neighborhood? You "save" $1M by building there versus a $1M more expensive land option in Great Falls, but you might "lose $300k" since there isn't a market for it.

Yes that new house is more marketable in Great Falls, but the lot would have cost $2M (vs your $800k), and add a $1M house on it and you would have to sell it for $3m in Great falls vs $2M in your area. So it is all relative.

I looked up ALL sales in your zip code 22312. There have been only 7 homes that have asked for over $1.25M. 5 were in Pinecrest, so for one, you are in the most expensive neighborhood in that zipcode.

The two highest started at $1.6M and $1.5M and closed at $1.3 and $1.2.

So yes, building a place that would require a $2M sales price would be a zip code record, and therefore very risky! You bought your house for $900k (maybe worth now $800k). How much is the cost to build what you want to build? Over $700k? Only $400k? All that matters too.

Generally speaking, you've heard that you don't want to have the best house on the block, and that still applies here.

But then again if you have a 10 year horizon, love where you are living, can make it tasteful and not too McMansiony, you might make $300k more elsewhere, but does that really matter?

I personally would never do it because I hate construction. Too many things go wrong, it ALWAYS costs much more, and the mental hasslefactor for doing a one off isn't worth it for me. As a builder that can do 5-10 and have a system in place, great. But making just one, would result in stress and therapy beyond any savings vs just buying (for more) that perfect house elsewhere. Or better yet, RENT! You can get an AMAZING deal renting mansions!

So now I take your question and I flip it around:

You bought in 2005. Are you willing to take a $20,000 to $80,000 loss to sell your place?

The initial gut reaction might be "hell no." But what if you bought a place that was $100,000 or $200,000 from it's high. So effectively you are trading up, fairly efficiently. You could wait until your house is back to break even, but I can guarantee you that the $1.5-$2M that you are looking at now, will have gone up by the same %. Same %, means double the actual dollar amount*. (*yes higher priced homes sometimes have different problems in selling, but you get my point)

Hope that helps,

- Written by Frank Borges LL0SA- Virginia Broker FranklyRealty.com (please report typos)

1 comment:

jenniferwelch said...

I love your blog. Essay writing practice has a lot of benefits. Earlier, it was very difficult for me to finish up long answers, since my language skill was not even up to the average. It was so pity that teachers couldn’t even understand what was written by me. When I forget any words, my total answer loses its meaning. But, later on I started practicing essays and I was in at a point to write answers in my own words. Thus I could impress my teacher as well. Go for best essay writing service here.
I want to share some points that I think one should keep in mind when they are writing an essay. Always chart the essay prior to writing it. Take a paper, and start noting down all your points and ideas. Then sort them in a good structure. Be sure that you have enough amounts of examples to support your basic points. Then start writing. This will save your time later. You will not stop and think while you are writing.
Remember that the first line of your essay should be interesting. Start with a story, or a quote, or making a brave claim. Just something that isn’t boring. It has to be good enough to grasp the reader’s interest and make them feel like they want to know more about the topic. Do not write lengthy sentences. The aim of an essay is to communicate ideas and your point of views in a simple way. But, that doesn’t mean that your essay needs to be weak. It just needs to be clear and should be able to do fairness to what you need to express. Avoid doing using first person pronouns that is ‘I’. Try to bring out a third person as it is more professional. Avoid ambiguity. Your main idea should be ideally clear. Do not hike on and on without simplifying just what you are getting at. The reader must know from the very first para what your position is.